top of page

REVIEW: Greek Myth Meets Theatre Magic at City of Fairfax Theatre Company’s Argonautika

Oct 9
6 min read

A legendary pelt. An impossible quest. A team-up of the greatest heroes ever seen. A boat. Argonautika boasts it all plus much more. Based on the original Greek myths and written by Mary Zimmerman, Argonautika follows the story of Jason, a prince conspired against by his conniving uncle, Pelias, and his band of heroes as they attempt to brave seas never sailed before by man on their ship—the Argo—to retrieve the fabled Golden Fleece of their countrymen. But Jason and his Argonauts encounter so much more than they could have imagined. With monsters, men, and gods in between them and the fleece, Jason discovers what it means to be a hero, and the consequences that result.


@emmacrawfordphotography
@emmacrawfordphotography

Walking into the show, before a single actor is visible, the first thing that strikes you about this show is the bespoke artistic design. The play’s poster comprises a gorgeous, hand-painted scene of Medea, created by the talented Madeline Bowden (@mae_lino). Being housed in the City of Fairfax Theatre Company’s blackbox theater, the set, designed by Olivia Hinebaugh, is front and center in such an intimate space. Without the often-seen proscenium design, the set takes full advantage of the space, immersing the audience with tangles of nets, ropes, a master in center stage, and a painted floor of an expansive night sky speckled with brilliant constellations (painted by Katie Brunberg and Kaya Thomas). And welcoming the audience to the show is the production’s director, Joshua McCreary. CFTC is lucky to have found such a passionate director as Josh, as it’s clear how much thought and care was put into everything this show has to offer, all with a clear, focused artistic direction.


Jason, the primary Argonaut, is portrayed by Aiden Abraham. When given a fool’s errand by his uncle, he puts out a call to the greatest heroes of the land, and like an ancient Nick Fury, pulls together his band of Greek “Avengers.” Abraham navigates the ups and downs of this character with aplomb, showing us the many sides of this historically-complex character. From the heroic adventurer to the wooing lover to his final years in history, Abraham wholly embodies the character, and does so with just one sandal. Jason is guided on his journey by two goddesses. First seen as a frail old woman trying to cross a river, Liz Owerbach immaculately transitions from comedic to dramatic as she transforms into the regal queen of the gods, Hera. Owerbach nails the aura of the woman situated at the pinnacle of Mt. Olympus, and is a constant guiding force not just for Jason, but for the production as a whole. Hera is contrasted with her fellow Olympian, Athena, goddess of wisdom and warfare. Played by Mikaela Fenn, Athena is a no-nonsense warrior who hand-crafts the mast of the Argo itself. Fenn’s portrayal of Athena feels grounded and relatable to the audience. Of all the gods in the show, she feels the most human. At times, it feels like she is the voice of reason, speaking what the audience wants to say and feeling what the audience is feeling. With so many characters with pre-existing relationships coming into the story, Argonautika is a show that relies heavily on chemistry, and the chemistry between Hera and Athena is incredibly strong. Their connection had myself and the rest of the audience hanging on every word.



The Argo would be nothing without its Argonauts, and boy, did it have them in spades. The Argonauts made themselves known bombastically and musically, setting up the tone that the show would have throughout, ranging from deathly serious to seriously silly (and everything in between). With almost everyone in the cast playing multiple roles, the cast’s range is squarely on display. Katie Brunberg is a delightful villain as a cruel, plotting uncle of Jason, King Pelias, and as the Argo’s faithful and competent helmsman, Tiphys, she shows off her more dramatic chops. Ennis Shabab and Rhodri Mendenhall portray the half-brothers Castor and Pollux with an endearing brotherly connection. Justin Beland’s turn as Idmon stands out as one of the more poignant sub-stories of the Argonauts. Playing a seer who perhaps has seen more than he might have wanted, Beland’s gravitas shines through, setting an undercurrent of portentous expectation throughout the story. Playing a figure tied to one of Idmon’s visions, Fabian Friedrich’s Meleger captures the heart of so many confident Greek heroes. His energy on stage was infectious, whether it was being poured into comedy or braggadocio. Speaking of braggarts, Kai Yoffe’s portrayal of the legendary hero Hercules was the perfect encapsulation of this show. From boasting about killing the snakes sent to suffocate him as a child, to showing off physical feats and dynamic poses to his fellow Argonauts, his presence was not to be ignored. And while his physicality was impressive, more impressive was his relationship with his companion Hylas (Caleb Cecil). From the start, you couldn’t help but enjoy the friendship between these two. Cecil’s earnest love for his friend complemented Yoffe’s earnest love for himself, and their lovable dynamic made their final scene together that much more affecting.


But enough about the Argonauts. The show featured far more than just these heroes. The voyage of the Argo was fraught with peril, full of encounters with monsters, gods, and mortals. John Geddie portrayed the arrogant Amycus, the giant king of the Bebrycians. Geddie’s humor—a shift from his more serious role as Meleger’s uncle—made the scene so memorable, as he fought his legendary boxing match against Pollux. And in another display of the show’s keen humor, Molly Hanrahan portrayed Eros, the original Greek version of Cupid. Or, as described by his mother, Aphrodite, portrayed by Kate Bierly, the “worst little boy.” Hanrahan’s comedic bits and capricious antics, contrasted by Bierly’s utter fury about having to deal with him, had the audience in stitches the entire time they were on stage, providing a much-appreciated jolt of levity and laughter in the latter parts of the play.



Finally, anyone who knows the story of Jason and the Argonauts knows one particular figure that could never be left out. On a personal note, Medea by Euripides is one of the earliest shows I was part of in this area. The story of Medea, the sorceress princess of Colchis, is a difficult one to portray, with the character at the heart of it being a very deep and multifaceted role, so my expectations were high. Valerie Pesot did not meet expectations—she blew them out of the water. Pesot’s performance as Medea was enthralling. Vacillating between the life she knew before the Argonauts arrived and her sudden feelings since, she personified so skillfully a woman who finds herself suddenly used as a pawn in the plots of gods and men. She is at once sympathetic and frightening, meek and imposing, certain and afraid. Pesot’s Medea alone was worth the price of admission, and I would be eager for a ticket if she ever decided to take up this role again in another telling of Medea’s story.



The production was bolstered by a strong technical creative team. Patricia Talmadge’s lightning design transformed the set from sea to island to desert, masterfully making use of the space’s lighting arrangement and—alongside the sound design which included a functioning wind sound machine—helping make the production that much more immersive. Misha McVay’s costumes and Alexa Yarboro’s props were a one-two punch, marrying the ancient with some contemporary, fitting for the production’s tone. Two standout elements are Hercules’s Golf Bag of Many Weapons and Medea’s striking costume that echoed the poster’s design. Lastly, movement was an exceptionally strong component of the production. The scenes flowed seamlessly into each other, as the set was arranged and rearranged to fit the needs of the scenes, and the actors flowed, as well. From the very first formation of the cast invoking the Muses, to the Argonaut Shabooya Roll Call, to a Hulk-handed boxing match, to an intimate interpretive dancing love scene, and every movement in-between, the skills of fight and intimacy director Olivia Hinebaugh and movement specialist Jessie Holder Tourtellotte were on full display.


Argonautika was a tour de force of acting, creativity, and artistry that I won’t soon forget. It is refreshing to see a show where everything feels so intentional and meaningful. I can only hope that the cast and crew had as much fun putting it all together as I had watching it. Though the characters themselves are ancient, they feel so relatable and real. They may deal with fantastical monsters, immortal gods, and magical spells, but the characters’ stories in Argonautika are ultimately human in nature. This production is a testament not only to the skill of the artists involved in it, but also to the enduring legacy of these characters, to the fact that, millennia later, we are still seeing ourselves in them. It is a reminder that the past is never truly past. These stories live on, written in the stars.


Argonautika ran September 11 through September 27, 2026 at 11216 Waples Mill Rd, Suite 103, Fairfax, VA 22030.

Comments


©2022 by YAM Productions. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page